CCLC responds to DfE school exclusions consultation and Milburn review

The government consultation on school exclusion reform ends tonight (19.11.2026). The three main policies under consultation are:

  • Internal suspension: introducing a clear, time-limited framework for internal suspension, allowing pupils who have been removed from the classroom for disciplinary reasons to remain on-site and maintain continuity of education, while signalling that suspension is for serious disciplinary reasons.
  • Reintegration support partnerships: a process for reintegration following a suspension which will involve a formal meeting leading to an agreed plan with clear responsibilities to help ensure parents play an active part in supporting their child’s reflection and successful reintegration after a suspension.
  • Provision of schoolwork during the first 5 days of suspension and permanent exclusion: to minimise disruption to learning and avoid time-consuming catch up, schoolwork is expected to be set and completed during the first five days of a suspension and permanent exclusion.

CCLC broadly supports the proposed reforms, particularly the requirement to provide education during the first five days of exclusion, helping to reduce lost learning and maintain pupils’ engagement with education. We also welcome the strengthened focus on reintegration following exclusion, provided that engagement with the process is not made a condition of readmission to school or lead to further sanctions where children or families struggle, or refuse, to participate.

Internal suspension is a positive development in principle, helping to keep pupils in school, reduce lost learning and avoid some of the risks associated with exclusion, including Child Criminal Exploitation (CCE). However, safeguards will be essential to ensure it is not overused or applied disproportionately to pupils with additional needs. There is a risk that, without clear limits, internal suspension becomes a means of keeping pupils out of the classroom for extended periods while avoiding the safeguards and scrutiny that accompany external exclusion, much in the same way that concerns have been raised about the use of removal (isolation) as a de facto form of exclusion.

The new framework should provide greater clarity on how internal suspension differs from other in-school practices that remove pupils from the classroom, particularly removal. A recent Department for Education blog states that internal suspension should be supervised, structured, time-limited and focused on learning and reintegration, contrasting it with removal, which it describes as a situation where “a child is placed alone with very limited interaction”. However, this sits uneasily with the existing guidance on removal (pgs 22-25, Behaviour in schools), which states that removal should be supervised, meaningful and accompanied by appropriate support for reintegration, alongside other safeguards, so this may need further consideration to prevent duplication. Secondly, the principles identified by the Department in relation to internal suspension, namely that it should be supervised, structured, time-limited and focused on learning and reintegration, are difficult to disagree with. However, it is not clear why these should be regarded as distinctive features of internal suspension rather than minimum expectations whenever a pupil is removed from the classroom. If these safeguards are considered important for internal suspension, there appears to be no obvious reason why they should not apply equally to other in-school practices that remove pupils from the classroom.

Alan Milburn review

We welcome Alan Milburn’s call for the Government to address school exclusions as part of its plan to improve the lives of young people. It is welcome that the review sets an aim to reduce both the overall use of exclusion and the significant variation between local areas. The consequences of exclusion are very significant for a child and, as the report states, excluded children are more likely to become NEET.

The review recommends that pupils who are repeatedly suspended or permanently excluded should have a transition and participation plan, with a named lead responsible for coordinating what happens next. In the first instance, this role would sit with the school, with responsibility escalating to the local authority where concerns continue.

The review’s ambition-setting on school exclusions, alongside the Government’s proposed school exclusion reforms which it has just consulted on, are steps in the right direction and we welcome them.

As the Government continues its agenda to address school exclusions, we encourage further reforms to make the school exclusions process fairer for children and their families and to ensure that there is the necessary process, accountability and oversight when a child is excluded from school. Improving procedural fairness – and making sure children experience fair process – is part of how we reduce school exclusions and prevent the detachment Alan Milburn says lies behind the NEET descriptor.

Richard Oldershaw, Lead Adviser, at Coram Child Law Advice, said:

We welcome Alan Milburn’s call for the Government to address exclusions as part of its plan to improve the lives of young people. The consequences of exclusion are very significant for a child and, as the report states, excluded children are more likely to become NEET.

The Government’s proposed school exclusion reforms are a step in the right direction and we broadly welcome them. But we encourage further reforms to make the process fairer for children and their families and to ensure that there is the necessary process, accountability and oversight when a child is excluded from school.

TwitterLinkedInEmailPrint